State Farm® Insurance Agent Anthony Pelfrey
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
Gracie Pillow
November 15, 2024
"I am receiving a $400 refund from what they have been over charging me for. Check your bills and ask questions cause they will overcharge you and put it in their own pockets. Took over a year and a half to get my money back. Drop Pelfry as fast as possible! Also if you look at all of the reviews they only respond to people with high ratings."
Heather Church
September 16, 2024
"Amy Wicker is the most helpful insurance agent I have ever dealt with. She is honest and upfront with everything. I was treated like family. If she can’t offer you a better deal than the company you are with she will tell you. Definitely a person who cares for the customer!"
Maggie Dysinger
September 11, 2024
"Amy Wicker with State Farm Insurance has been a great help . If she doesn’t know an answer, she will do the research and ensure me with accurate information in a timely manner. Amy was even able to catch an issue with my previous insurance. Thank you Amy for all your help"
rachele richards
September 10, 2024
"Amy was very informative and helpful throughout the quote process, Thank you!"
Hazel Henthorne
September 10, 2024
"Had an informative meeting with Anthony Pelfrey and Amy Whicker at their State Farm office in Westerville today. It is a pleasure to meet those that are helping me protect and succeed in life! Thank you for taking the time to meet me in person!"
Ray Miller
September 10, 2024
"This young lady saved me money,she is very polite and answers all your questions. She is very quick to get back to you if you call her.I am very pleased with State Farm."
Sarah
June 21, 2024
"I work with Jake today on quotes for my home, auto, and umbrella policies. He was able to save me money on all three and provide more coverage than I had. I am thrilled about the savings and impressed by the professionalism of the office as a whole. I look forward to working with this insurance team!"
Gregory Freitag
June 21, 2024
"We were hit by the tornado at Indian Lake, Ohio on March 14th. The damage was extensive. And we were without power for 4 days in freezing temperatures. Bethany Groves at Anthony Pelfrey Insurance Agency was quick to get us money for repairs and she was compassionate in addressing our needs. I gave her a 5 out of a possible 5. I will do a follow-up review after we have fixed all the damage. I take my hat off to Bethany! Sincerely, Greg F."
"Thanks, Greg! We are happy you had such a great experience with Bethany. She’s one of the best!"
Bryce Lang
May 15, 2024
"Anthony’s team, specifically Ashley, are so great! Always able to get timely responses and she is always kind."
"Ashley is great! Thanks for the wonderful review, Bryce!"
Jung Le
April 18, 2024
"Bethany Groves provides excellent service and has helped me in more ways than I can count. As a long distance real estate investor, I rely on her to manage the home insurance needs of my various rentals, and she not only provides me great service, she does so with patience, consideration, and diligence. Communication with Bethany is always prompt and pleasant. You can depend on Bethany to take care of you! ***** Jake Parker provided fast and effective service. He was diligent and communicated well, offering a competitive quote that I needed within a short turnaround time. Much appreciated, Jake from State Farm!"
"🥹🥹 aww, Jung! We are in our feels over here about your kind words. Thanks so much!"
Kassi Younker
April 4, 2024
"I have been with State Farm for years and mostly because of Bethany’s excellent customer service! She is amazing! If you are looking for Great service and Great insurance you should switch over to Anthony Pelfrey’s office 😊"
"Thanks, Kassi! We appreciate you and thank you for trusting us!"
Michael Pizzurro
February 21, 2024
"Since I left USAA. I have 100% assistance with State Farm. Having each agent explain in detail, options of coverage is very helpful. My memory goes out at times. Yet these agents are more than polite and treat it just as if it was the first time i asked. The two young ladies, i speak with. Ashley, & Bethany. Above standards. have texted, emailed from work or home. Even left voicemails with the replies, or answers. This is always a plus. Most folks can't wait or be in one place at the drop of a concern. I am thankful to have State Farm to insure my needs, especially with an affordable price."
"Michael - thank you. Sincerely, thank you. We strive to make sure everyone is comfortable with the protection we provide and we never mind educating people more than once, if needed. Thanks for letting us be there for you!"
Kaitlin Brown
January 9, 2024
"I have been working with Anthony for nearly 2 years now and always am more than satisfied with the help and services he provides. Him and his staff are beyond personable and genuinely want to do what’s best for you in whatever situation you are in and will meet you where you are. He does an excellent job at explaining your options and is always more than happy to help. I couldn’t be more happy with my experience thus far and look forward to continuing to work with him in the future."
"Thanks, Kaitlin! It’s never about what we think you need - it’s about what YOU feel like you need. We’re just here to ask the right questions and present options for you. We’re glad you’re here!"
Patty Williams
January 6, 2024
"My husband and I have been with State Farm for many years. Anthony is an amazing agent! He and his staff are very friendly, always attentive to my needs, and always available when I have a question or concern! If your current agent does not fit this bill, please give Anthony a call! You will not be disappointed, and probably save some money on your coverage!"
"Aww, Patty - thank you! You are very much appreciated!"
morgan pillow
December 14, 2023
"Honestly, unprofessional office and won't even respond to my numerous emails I have sent them regarding my auto insurance. Going to have to switch because overall this is just bleh. I wrote a previous review and still have yet to even get a response, email, or call."
morgan pillow
November 15, 2023
"I have yet to receive an email back I emailed on October 31st and it is now November 15th. They overcharged me by more than $100. The ladies who answer the phone are unprofessional and rude. I have been spoken down too by the secretaries and honestly just would not recommend this place at all. I like Statefarm just not this agents office. I have been with Statefarm for a very long time however the quality has just dropped off."
Jennifer Walker
November 10, 2023
"Very helpful and knowledgeable"
"Thanks, Jennifer!"
Eric Lopez
October 3, 2023
"Jake Parker was a huge help! He doubled the coverage I had with a competitor and reduced my payment beyond belief. Quick, thorough, easy to work with, and overall a really nice guy."
Beth W
August 30, 2023
"Sarah took great care of us at our insurance checkup. She explains concepts really well."
Natalie Nau
August 16, 2023
"5 stars! Sarah was great to work with, she walked me through everything, and answered all my questions thoroughly! She really took the time to explain anything I didn’t understand."
Robbie Quinn
August 9, 2023
"Thank You Sarah Hall for reaching out and saving me a lot of money and I wish I had switched sooner!"
Jason Wilcox
August 1, 2023
"Sarah was prompt and friendly in helping with my insurance needs. Thank you!"
Rex Wenger
July 21, 2023
"Excellent service. I left a message and my call was returned in a timely manner. I am thinking adding pet insurance."
Brava A
July 14, 2023
"Sarah provided excellent customer service! She made me want to actually look at my USAA rates....:)"
Ivan Kramarenko
July 13, 2023
"Good service. Good price."